An easy recipe that transforms regular graham crackers into dreamy butter
When I fall for something, I fall hard. Remember my smoothie obsession? And my salad obsession? And of course, my granola obsession?
Well, another thing is simple nut butter sandwiches. But I have a confession – I take those two slices of bread and innocent cashew butter – and add some sinful toppings.
Like cookie butter.
& chocolate chips.
(& leftover Easter candy.)
I was using store bought cookie butter. Of course, I considered making my own, but remember that time I ate a whole jar in two days! So, I thought it might be a wee too dangerous to have homemade in my reach.
But then, these leftover graham crackers from this Key Lime Pie were calling my name.
I’ll admit I was a bit skeptical this would be as delicious as say Biscoff. The first time I had it I thought – hmm – kinda bland. But then I fell in love. & have made several batches since.
If you want to take your PB&J from ordinary to extraordinary, I highly recommend you add some of this Graham Cracker Butter.
Today Iโm sharing this recipe on My Cooking Spot, so be sure to check it out.
Or stick around here and check out this Coconut Cashew Butter.
Looking for more recipes with nut/cookie butters? Check out these favorites:
- Cashew Butter Granola
- Cookie Butter Lovers’ Cookies
- Cashew Butter Cookie Dough Stuffed Oreos
- Cashew Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Is there anything you’re currently obsessed with?
Okay, confession: I’ve never had cookie butter. I know, I know! I’m just afraid that if I try it, I won’t be able to stop eating it. It’s an actual concern I have.
This looks amazing, though. I might have to break my resolve!
It is really dangerous! But I highly recommend anyway ๐ Thanks Mir!
Oh no! I think I’m falling hard for this one too Megan! I’ve had store bought cookie butter, but I’ve never tried making my own! On my list!
You have to try it! Thanks Mary Ann ๐
I could SO eat about 5 sandwiches in a row made with this deliciousness! Yowza!
Me too!! Ha ha! Thanks Kate ๐
Graham cracker butter?! Such a great idea!
Thanks Gayle!
I need to make my own GF cookie butter is I ever want to try it!
You should! Thanks Rebecca ๐
I have never made or had a cookie butter. But this one here looks so dreamy. Can’t to try it for myself. Thanks for this awesome share!
You have to try it! Thanks Anu ๐
Oh wow, I think this could be trouble. It looks so dangerous and delicious! Yum!
Not quite as dangerous as store bought ๐ Thanks Karen!
Oh wow – Megan – this looks fantastic – and I love that it’s only 2 ingredients! I’d never attempted to make my own cookie butter – or even thought to combine it with nut butters – and oooh – leftover Easter candy!
ha ha! You have to try it – so easy and so delicious! Thanks Shashi ๐
Cookie butter…how fun!
It is! Thanks Angie ๐
I get obsessed with things too, Megan! So I know the struggle is real! ๐ I’ve had nut butters and cookie butter before, but graham cracker butter?! GENIUS! I bet this is dangerously delicious! I MUST try!!! Cheers, chicka! <3
Thanks Cheyanne! You should try it!
Looks like trouble. I could eat ato of this stuff
A little trouble is good sometimes ๐ Thanks John!
I’m definitely the same way when it comes to food obsessions ๐ This graham cracker butter would be one of them! Love this idea – so fun and creative!
Thanks Kelly! It is delicious ๐
OMG such a great idea!!!!
Thanks Allie!!
Oh my gosh, this looks AMAZING. I adore adore adore grahams. I think putting them in a spoon would be dangerous for me — but worth it!
You’ve got that right, Annie! So dangerous, but definitely worth it ๐
This is a great post! Thanks for sharing, yummy! ๐ looks delicious! Xx
Thanks for the kind words, Linda!
Whattt??? Graham cracker butter? I love this! I always buy a box and then barely use any for a recipe … and then have tons extra! Heading to check this out!
That was my problem! It’s a great use for them. Thanks Ashley ๐
Cooking can be dangerous! We don’t want any of that delicious food to go to waste….right! This looks like a very addicting dip!
Absolutely! Thanks Kathy ๐
I’m already obsessed with cookie butter. Graham cracker butter sounds like the next best thing!
It is! Thanks Eva ๐
Mmmm….I love this idea for homemade cookie butter! I think I’d smear it on everything ๐ Off to see your recipe…
Thanks Liz!! I’ve only had it on sandwiches, but I bet it would be delicious elsewhere too!!
How neat! I’ve never heard of graham cracker butter before but I’m loving it, such a cool recipe!
Thanks Katie! I had the GCs and thought – hey, why not make butter ๐
Wow! Iโve never even heard of this before and it sounds amazing! Who doesnโt love graham crackers and the recipe is so easy and simple to make with just 2 ingredients… Love it
Thanks Rahul! It’s a great way to use surplus GCs – if you have any ๐
This is SUCH a great idea! I don’t care for cookie butter as it’s a bit sweet, but I love graham crackers and think this looks delicious!
Thanks Marcie! I think this would be perfect for you because it is milder than regular cookie butter ๐
So, graham crackers in general are so addicting to me! Every time I buy them I just keep nibbling away. And I totally don’t buy cookie butter because I bought it once and ate like a whole jar in 2 days too!! Ha.
I’ve actually eaten a whole box of graham crackers in about two days, too! Whoops! Thanks so much for visiting, Nicole ๐
What a fascinating idea! I personally think of you as my cookie butter/nut butter friend. ๐ How could I possibly forget your delicious cashew butter granola? It’s so interesting that you only used 2 ingredients for this! You can really make butter out of anything, huh? Loved seeing you on My Cooking Spot, friend. ๐ Have a wonderful weekend. xoxo
Thanks Demeter!! & that granola is sooo delicious ๐
Wow Megan, awesome share. My stomach is growling at these pictures. ๐
ha ha! Thanks Puja ๐
I’ve wanted to try a homemade cookie butter, but it seems even better with graham cracker! But I don’t see the recipe in the post?
It is delicious! You can find the recipe on My Cooking Spot where I am a contributor ๐
I have never thought of graham cracker butter – it makes sense, because I love homemade graham cracker crust. Love this idea! ๐
Yes! Graham cracker crust is the best! Thanks Vanessa ๐
Graham cracker butter?!! Now that’s crazy delicious GENIUS!!! Can’t wait to give it a try Megan!!
ha ha! Thanks Ami ๐
Wait…graham cracker butter?! This is such an incredible idea…and I had no idea you could make it at home. You’re a culinary wizard, Megan! We are huge fans of Biscoff over here (we’ve even been to the factory in Belgium!), so anything that reminds me of Biscoff is sure to be a winner…and is sure to disappear within hours not days. Thanks for this recipe…hopping over to check it out now!
I love Biscoff, too! I bet the factory is so cool. I’ll have to check it out someday. Thanks David!